Single Stage vs Two Stage vs Variable Capacity Furnaces (Complete Analysis)

If you live in a place that gets very cold and snowy in the winter, you have to have a furnace. Thanks to their easy and quick heating process, furnaces can be great companions to help you get through the teeth-shattering, hair-raising winter.

It is important to remember that the size of a furnace plays an important role in the type and complexity of your home's heating system. While you should always opt for a unit that will best suit the heating needs of your home, it can be a daunting task at first to familiarize yourself with all of the models, sizes, and types of furnaces.

It's best to start from the basics, and the basics start by enlisting the different kinds of furnaces, including those that vary in their capacity. In fact, if you’ve already done some research, you might have come across the distinct single-stage, two-stage, and variable-capacity furnaces.

When choosing a new furnace, the most important thing for most homeowners is to figure out which of the three they need. Before we get into the specifics of features and quality, here are brief descriptions of the main types of furnaces:

A single-stage furnace is one that constantly runs to its fullest capacity, i.e., at 100%.
A two-stage furnace runs at 70% capacity while having the potential of running at 100%.
A variable capacity or “modulating” furnace can operate at a range of 40 to 100% capacity.

These differences can largely affect how comfortable you feel in your home and whether your furnace is able to create the right conditions for you, taking the surroundings into account. However, differences can also be found in cost and efficiency rates among the different models.

Quick Comparison Single vs Two vs Variable Capacity Furnace - Defining Different Model Types of Furnaces

Single-stage furnaces are known for their low prices and cheap repair costs. These furnaces don't promise to be very efficient, which makes them a little less appealing.

A loud and constantly running blower motor is another thing about single-stage furnaces that isn't talked about enough. These motors run at full speed for as long as the unit is turned on, which can cause quite a bit of noise.

On the other hand, both parts and replacements for two-stage furnaces cost about the same, and their efficiency ranges from low-cost units that work well to those that work well and save money.

Their efficiencies are determined on the basis of both how frequently the model is used and the stage at which it is used: 65%, 75%, or even 100%. Unlike single-stage units, these furnaces run slowly but steadily so that the heating cycle lasts longer and there are fewer changes in temperature.

Lastly, variable-capacity furnaces are known for being able to control the temperatures inside and outside without making a lot of noise. In terms of lifespan and durability, however, variable-capacity furnaces are known to be a little weak in this area, while single-stage and two-stage models come with strong and lasting builds.

Variable-capacity furnaces have the highest outright costs of any model type. Owners of these furnaces will have to indulge in high installation and replacement costs. However, they will also be able to experience startlingly low return costs thanks to the high efficiency of these units.

Single-stage vs Two-stage vs Variable Capacity furnaces: An Elaborate Differentiation - Single Stage vs Two Stage vs Variable Capacity Furnaces

Now that you know the main differences between the three types of furnaces, it's time to dig deeper and look at other things that affect how they work.

Hopefully, this will help give you an insight into what kind of furnace would be most suitable for meeting your personal, home, and lifestyle needs.

The Number of Heating Stages - Differences Between Model Types of Furnaces

The main distinction between furnaces is the number of heating stages. In fact, the word "furnace" comes from this idea. If you haven’t figured it out already, single-stage or two-stage furnaces are named that way with reference to the number of heating stages a model has.

The gas valve controls the heating stages, which are mostly different between the three models. The difference, then, comes down to the fact that:

Single-stage gas furnaces have gas valves that can open all the way up to 100%.

This means that if a furnace's capacity is set at, say, 12,000 BTU, the gas valve will open all the way and constantly push 12,000 BTU out of the unit while it's running.

Similarly, two-stage gas furnaces have gas valves that open at two different stages or capacities. These capacities could be 100% or 70%.

Depending on the mode of operation, the gas valve could let out a full 10,000 BTU worth of heating in a 10,000 BTU furnace (at 100% capacity) or it could open up enough to heat at about 7,000 BTU for the same furnace (at 70% capacity).

Unlike the other model types, variable-capacity furnaces have gas valves that allow them to operate at any heating level between 40% and 100% of the furnace's capacity.

Thus, in a 10,000 BTU furnace, the heating stage could range from 4,000 to 10,000 BTUs depending on the need of the hour. This is why these are also called modulating furnaces.

Temperature Balance - Differences Between Model Types of Furnaces

When it comes to gas furnaces, whether they can create a good and stable temperature in the given surroundings is the big question. Good temperature balance is the key to good heating.

When compared to the other types, single-stage furnaces are the most uncomfortable because the temperature changes so quickly. Temperatures can differ frequently, up to 4 degrees, and this can be quite taxing when all a homeowner wants is to be comfortable.

Two-stage furnaces work better in this area because they are designed to always heat at a lower level instead of at full power. This significantly reduces temperature swings and spaces them only 1-2 degrees apart.

Variable-capacity furnaces are great for reducing temperature swings because they run at the lowest capacity needed to keep the house warm.

Air Filtration - Differences Between Model Types of Furnaces

Two-stage and variable-capacity furnaces have shown more promise in air filtration.

This is a result of their long cycles, which keep the air moving through the ducts and filters so that the air can be cleaned and circulated better. Things like dust, debris, and pet dander are successfully removed.

Single-stage furnaces, which are designed to work at full capacity, don’t have as many cycles and tend to be negligent in filtering the air appropriately.

Costs - Differences Between Model Types of Furnaces

The next point of distinction, which inarguably affects most customers today, is the cost. The cost of a product is usually a total estimate of the numbers it draws from your wallet throughout its lifetime, from the moment it is bought.

Therefore, costs are divided into:

Initial cost: the cost of purchasing and installing the furnace unit.
Operating cost (return cost): the cost incurred during the duration of running the product. These costs have a lot to do with the efficiency of the product. The higher the efficiency, the lower the operating costs.
Repair costs: the expenses that repairs or replacement components would incur when the furnace malfunctions or breaks.

Single-stage furnaces have very low initial costs compared to the other models. This is because of the manufacturing, as this type of furnace has a simple and structured build without many intricacies.

Additionally, its single heat exchanger does not increase the number on the price tag by a large amount. Even when it comes to how much it costs to fix them, these models have shown low rates. This is because their technology is strong but easy to look at and fix.

Repair costs for single-stage furnaces are thus lower as well. However, these furnaces really take the hit regarding operating costs. As you know, single-stage units have very low efficiency. Naturally, their return and operating costs are higher.

Two-stage gas furnaces incur more initial costs than single-stage furnaces. When highly efficient models are involved, they are more expensive as they require an extra heat exchanger.

Repairs are also easy and quite cheap to manage, as they have been proven to have strong frames. Most two-stage furnaces are energy efficient, so you can expect their operating costs to be quite low, though this varies from model to model.

Variable-capacity furnaces are said to be integrated with high and complex technology, so you can expect them to be on the expensive side of things.

Because of their construction, their repair costs are also higher in the event of any faulty functional parts. However, due to their high efficiency rates, one can expect that these models are more generous when returning electricity costs.

An Overall Comparison: Which Furnace is the Best? - Single Stage vs Two Stage vs Variable Capacity Furnaces

When you’re trying to answer questions where you expect one product to reign supreme over the others, you must understand that the answer depends solely on your preferences and needs.

Single-stage furnaces usually work well in small, single-story homes where the temperature changes very little from room to room. Thus, there is a lesser need for modulating furnaces.

On the other hand, two-stage and variable capacity furnaces can be very useful in houses that span over a large area or have multiple floors, as temperature changes may be drastic in different parts of the house. These furnaces will be able to help modulate and balance the temperatures.

Variable capacity and two-stage furnaces are also great options for all-year-round heating, especially during the fall or spring months. Single-stage furnaces generally give out full-blown heating at all times and are likely to be helpful only in the coldest of months.

Single-stage furnaces are also not the most favorable in terms of energy savings. They use more power to start up and turn off than two-stage and variable-capacity furnaces, which only change speeds to fit the environment. Also notable: single-stage furnaces are more prone to damage.

Two-stage and variable-capacity furnaces don't always run at full capacity, so they use less energy and wear out the unit less quickly. Variable-capacity, or “modulating,” furnaces are a great way to make sure that heat is spread as evenly as possible in big houses with more than one floor.

Conclusion - Single Stage vs Two Stage vs Variable Capacity Furnaces

It is important to remember that the size of a furnace has a big effect on the type and complexity of the heating system in your home. All three furnace types have their own advantages and disadvantages over the others. In modern homes, dual-stage or variable-capacity furnaces have more benefits than single-stage units.

Still, aspects like climate and home design can make it so that a single-stage unit is most suitable for you. A careful evaluation of all these factors will lead you to the right choice.

Consider how important aspects like energy efficiency, noise, cost, area, and climate affect you. You should always choose a heater that will best meet your home's heating needs.

If, on the other hand, choosing which model type would work best for your house still scares you, know that there are many ways to get help. You should be able to determine your needs with the aid of an HVAC provider. These businesses will be able to use their expertise to suggest air systems and appliances they think will work best for your home.

Related Articles You May Like